Light Gets Brighter

Jehovah’s Witnesses claim to be the only group to have truth revealed to them by Jehovah. In this case, why do they require ongoing changes in doctrine? Does truth really change? A key premise of this site is that constant changes in doctrine and failed predictions are a clear indication that Jehovah does not direct the Watchtower Society. For the external observer this is the logical conclusion, yet for a Jehovah’s Witness it barely raises a grimace. How can this be? Because changes and failures are immediately dismissed by the thought stopping concept:

“The Bible tells us the light would get brighter.”

Addressing the flawed logic of this claim is required to render the information contained within this site effective.

The main justification from the Watchtower for changed doctrine is Proverbs 4:18:

“But the path of the righteous ones is like the bright light that is getting lighter and lighter until the day is firmly established.”

To interpret “light” as referring to Watchtower “doctrinal” understanding is simply justification for prior error. Aspects to consider are:

  • Is Watchtower doctrine getting brighter or changing?
  • Watchtower Justification for Error
  • What is the intended meaning of Proverbs 4:18?
  • Would Jehovah direct a religion to promote falsehood?

Brighter light is used to explain why previous doctrine was wrong. It is never presented as showing that current doctrine is likely to also be wrong. Yet that is the result if the Brighter light justification is applied to current truth.

Brighter or Changed

Proverbs 4 is discussing that righteous people fare better than the wicked. But let us entertain the idea that this Scripture contains a prophetic meaning that Jehovah would progressively reveal truth to his people at the time of the end. This concept cannot apply to Watchtower history, as Watchtower doctrine has not refined but changed. Consider whether the following change is really a matter of doctrinal light getting lighter:

Imagine being the Witness parent of a child that needed a kidney transplant in 1970. Although the Awake! 1949 Dec. 22 had described transplants as “wonders of modern surgery” in 1967 God revealed that transplants were wrong in his eyes. The Watchtower 1967 Nov. 15 pp.702-704 stated that being now “enlightened by God’s word” God’s people understood that transplants are against divine principles and cannibalistic. The parents must sincerely have believed they were putting Jehovah first when watching their child die, refusing them the opportunity of possible survival through a transplant. How would that parent feel on reading the Watchtower 1980 Mar. 15 p.31 – “There is no Biblical command pointedly forbidding the taking in of other human tissue . It is a matter for personal decision.” The enlightenment of 1967 had proved to be dark, harmful and in need of later correction, a regressive doctrine that resulted in the unnecessary death of members.

When a doctrine changes and then reverts back to the original position, this is not evidence of light getting brighter, it is evidence of a lack of Holy Spirit directing the Governing Body. Russell eloquently wrote the following truism:

“If we were following a man undoubtedly it would be different with us; undoubtedly one human idea would contradict another and that which was light one or two or six years ago would be regarded as darkness now; But with God there is no variableness, neither shadow of turning, and so it is with truth; any knowledge or light coming from God must be like its author. A new view of truth never can contradict a former truth. “New Light” never extinguishes older “light” but adds to it.” Zion’s Watch Tower 1881 Feb pp.3, 188

The concept of light becoming brighter implies that previous doctrine was correct, but incomplete. The Watchtower Society has promoted many significant doctrines that were later discarded as incorrect. Others have changed back and forth, even reverting to their original position, in each case contradicting a former truth.

It has regularly been the case that Watchtower doctrine is not illuminated but eclipsed. It was not increasing light that dictated:

  • In the 1950’s that Jesus was no longer to be worshipped; it was a fundamental teaching that was (or currently is) wrong
  • Failed date prophecies
  • Pyramids were prophetic of 1914
  • Superior Authorities were Goverments – God – Governments
  • The numerous changes to the meaning of the generation

These were not clarifications – these were wrong teachings. How many wrong teachings did God allow to become part of the Bible canon? Now compare that with how many wrong teachings are contained within the Watchtower over less then 150 years. Ongoing reversal of doctrine can only indicate God is not involved in these new flashes of light that later turn out to be falsehoods.

The Governing Body members have changed constantly over more than a century. New light, particularly when it is contradictory light, is just new opinions from new Governing Body members.

When is it truth?

This concept is applicable to any Christian religion similar to the Witnesses, such as Christadelphians and Church of God. Both of these have a doctrinal structure almost identical to Jehovah’s Witnesses. It has equal application to Seventh-day Adventists, who started concurrently with the Witnesses from the same basic teachings of Miller. Seventh-day Adventists preach and grow at the same rate. A person raised in any of these religions is equally convinced that the “light getting brighter” will clarify things wrong with their religion.

The Church of God uses the same “new light” reasoning, as shown in an experience of a member:

“Mr. Herbert W. Armstrong still took what seemed to me a less than candid approach. He called our Divorce & Remarriage change “new light,” “new truth” which God has (finally) shown us. In other words, he subtly blamed our doctrinal error on God.” (ex-sda.com 2 May 2006)

The following Watchtower article about the Catholic Church is equally applicable to the Watchtower Society.

“”Tell me,” he asked, “how can I have confidence in anything? How can I believe in the Bible, in God, or have faith? Just ten years ago we Catholics had the absolute truth, we put all our faith in this. Now the pope and our priests are telling us this is not the way to believe any more, but we are to believe ‘new things.’ How do I know the ‘new things’ will be the truth in five years?”” Awake! 1970 Apr 22 p.8

What the Bible Says

The Bible explains that the meaning of some truths were not to be understood until a later time. Nevertheless, this does not allow for Jehovah directing his people with falsehood.

John 16:13 “However, when that one arrives, the spirit of the truth, he will guide YOU into all the truth, for he will not speak of his own impulse, but what things he hears he will speak, and he will declare to YOU the things coming.”

At John 16:13, Jesus was referring to the outpouring of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost. Jesus did not refer to partial or incorrect truth; the Spirit would reveal truth, including “things coming”. As discussed in the section on dates , the Watchtower Society has had a 100% failure rate in predicting things “coming”.

Daniel 12:4, 10 “And as for you, O Daniel, make secret the words and seal up the book, until the time of [the] end. Many will rove about, and the [true] knowledge will become abundant… Many will cleanse themselves and whiten themselves and will be refined. And the wicked ones will certainly act wickedly, and no wicked ones at all will understand; but the ones having insight will understand.”

Though Daniel did not understand what he wrote, he did not make false interpretations. The Society’s interpretation of Daniel has changed constantly with explanations that were applied to the 1800’s now applied to the 1900’s. Despite this, the Organization insists that God only enlightens them to interpret these Scriptures accurately.

Rather than indicate that doctrine would get brighter or change, the Bible warns against anyone that promotes false doctrine.

1 John 4:1 “Beloved ones, do not believe every inspired expression, but test the inspired expressions to see whether they originate with God, because many false prophets have gone forth into the world.”

Galatians 1:8, 9 “But even though we, or an angel from heaven, should preach to you a gospel contrary to that which we have preached to you, let him be accursed. As we have said before, so I say again now, if any man is preaching to you a gospel contrary to that which you received, let him be accursed.”

Watchtower Justification for Doctrinal Error

Proverbs 4:18 is the primary justification for why much of early Watchtower doctrine has changed and continues to change. There are additional lines of reasoning that are invoked, but each is equally insipid.

Apostles Made Mistakes

The Watchtower justifies errors through a comparison with the Apostles and the mistakes that they made.

“Like the apostles of Jesus Christ, they have at times had some wrong expectations.” Reasoning from the Scriptures p.136

In a similar vein, I regularly receive emails from Witnesses that God used Moses, Abraham and David to lead his people even though they were sinners.

This addresses an issue quite different to the one at hand. This is not a question of individual Jehovah’s Witnesses or individual members of the Governing Body being perfect or holding to a perfect understanding of doctrine. The issue is whether the Governing Body operates under guidance of Holy Spirit as a collective group, after prayer. Does Jehovah direct what appears in the Watchtower journals?

Rather than suggesting that Apostles made mistakes, ask “What percentage of the Apostles writings in the Bible are wrong?” Zero percent. “What percentage of Watchtower statements has been wrong?” The difference being, the Apostles were directed by God, the Governing Body is not.

Since the Watchtower Governing Body is unlike the Apostles and not directed by God to arrive at doctrine, why follow them without question?

A Witness will say that the Governing Body are allowed doctrinal mistakes, as Bible leaders in the past made mistakes. But the issue is not whether individuals need be perfect, but whether their teachings are accurate. How many mistakes did God allow into the Bible?

God is testing us

Another justification has been used several times after Watchtower prophecies went unfulfilled. The Watch Tower 1916 Feb 1 said about the incorrect understanding of 1914:

“We inferred from this that the Church’s ‘change’ would take place on or before that date. But God did not tell us that it would be so. He permitted us to draw that inference; and we believe that it has proven to be a necessary test upon God’s dear saints everywhere.”

What sort of group would accuse God of allowing them to promote falsehood as a test of his followers? If false teachings are a test from God, how do we differentiate between one Church and the other?

Eager

Additional Watchtower justification for incorrect interpretations is to attribute them to eagerness. People that criticise this righteous eagerness are negatively trying to divert people from the importance of the times.

“It is easy for the established churches of Christendom and other people to criticize Jehovah’s Witnesses because their publications have, at times, stated that certain things could take place on certain dates. Have they not, rather, encouraged spiritual sluggishness by considering expectation of “the end” to be “meaningless” or “an insignificant myth”? Have apostates promoted Christian alertness? Have they not, rather, induced spiritual sleepiness?” Watchtower 1984 Dec 1 p.18

“Jehovah’s Witnesses, in their eagerness for Jesus’ second coming, have suggested dates that turned out to be incorrect.” Awake! 1993 Mar 22 p.4

“In modern times such eagerness, commendable in itself, has led to attempts at setting dates for the desired liberation from the suffering and troubles that are the lot of persons throughout the earth.” Watchtower 1980 Mar 15 p.17

In application to itself, the Watchtower insinuates that alertness is more important to truthfulness. In application to other religions sincerity is not enough, teaching untruths makes their followers unacceptable to God.

“For us to be acceptable to God, our sincere beliefs must be based on accurate information. Jehovah’s Witnesses in your community will be happy to assist you in examining what is involved in serving God with sincerity and truth.” Watchtower 2003 Feb 1 p.32 Sincerity-Desirable, but Is It Enough?

To be eager does not justify being totally wrong. Many religions are eager, without relying on false predictions to motivate their members. The Seventh-day Adventists use statements such as “See you later, God Willing” to show they recognise God may intervene at any stage. This is a healthy recognition of God’s timetable without encouraging serving to a date. Making mistakes in God’s name has not promoted long term eagerness; it has resulted in followers losing their faith in the Organization.

Proverbs 4:18

Proverbs 4:18 was not intended to be prophetic indication that God gradually reveals truth to the Watchtower Society. Rather than extract a sentence, when taken in entirety the context of Proverbs chapter 4 is a comparison of behaviour between good and bad people, not the dispensing of doctrinal truth through an organization. The surrounding verses say:

“the wicked do not sleep unless they do badness. … The way of the wicked ones is like the gloom; they have not known at what they keep stumbling … listen to the discipline of a father … keep my commandments … safeguard your heart.”

For thousands of years people have understood this scripture to be discussing behaviour.

“What is clear from Proverbs is that the reader can choose to either seek wisdom or live a life of folly. (Prov 4:14-19)” (thisischurch.com 25 Mar 2005)

Does Jehovah’s direction include falsehoods?

The Watchtower Society did not originate the concept of excusing failed predictions as “new light”. Barbour had used this concept to justify why the end did not arrive as predicted in 1874. Religions claiming to have all the answers consistently prove to be wrong. The Watchtower reliance on the “new light” doctrine is no more than an excuse to justify inaccuracies. “New light” is an unhealthy concept that promotes blind, unquestioning devotion to men.

Deuteronomy 18:20-22 provides a foolproof way to determine if words spoken have come from God:

“However, the prophet who presumes to speak in my name a word that I have not commanded him to speak or who speaks in the name of other gods, that prophet must die. And in case you should say in your heart: “How shall we know the word that Jehovah has not spoken?” when the prophet speaks in the name of Jehovah and the word does not occur or come true, that is the word that Jehovah did not speak. With presumptuousness the prophet spoke it.”

Watchtower changes include numerous false dates, significant doctrinal changes and the promotion of pagan symbols and teachings. Rules on shunning, medical advice and education have been adversely life changing, even life threatening. Falsehood does not originate from Jehovah. Doctrinal meandering cannot be justified as new light; rather it is proof that God does not direct the Watchtower Society.

Truth, in matter of religion, is simply the opinion that has survived – Oscar Wilde

6 thoughts on “Light Gets Brighter

  1. I’m one of Jehovah’s Witnesses. I truly believe that if you study the Bible with an open mind and an open heart and wiutoht outside influences you will come to the same basic understanding of the main doctrines as you will if you study with Jehovah’s Witnesses.BUT of course this is making certain assumptions. It is assuming that you don’t already have falsehood embedded in your consciousness by other things you have learned .Most of what Jehovah’s Witnesses find we have to do with people is not so much to teach them the Bible (that is the easy part) but to UNTEACH them things they’ve learned that are false. We have to help them to see that a lot of the things someone has already taught them is not true according to the scriptures.COULD you come to this conclusion on your own? I think that plenty have. I think certain ones have looked at the Bible and seen the scriptures about Jesus’ relationship with Jehovah and have correctly surmised that Jehovah is the father of Jesus, that Jesus is his son, that they are in unity in will and purpose, but that they are NOT the same person.But how easy is it to come to a conclusion like that even if it is clear it is what the Bible truly teaches? Peer pressure and the sheer WILL of those who want you to believe otherwise makes it hard to buck the flow even when it is clear by such scriptures as John 14:28, John 20:17, and Matthew 26:39 that Jehovah was greater than Jesus, was the God of Jesus, and that the two of them had two separate wills although Jesus was willing to submit to his Father’s will.Should you quit your study and study on your own? Personally I don’t think so. I think instead what you should do is to keep on studying WITH the Witnesses, and ALSO study on your own. Search the scriptures extensively and SEE if you can disprove anything they attempt to teach you.This way you will be following the examples of the Boreans in the Bible whom Paul preached to. He said that the Boreans were noble minded because while they accepted what they were being taught they ALSO diligently studied the scriptures daily as to whether what they were being taught was true.Remember that even the Ethiopian in the Bible who was a Jewish proselyte didn’t completely understand the scriptures wiutoht someone who knew a little more about them to guide him . When Phillip did guide him he rejoiced at his greater knowledge and accepted Jesus and was baptized in Jesus’ name.I was raised as one of Jehovah’s Witnesses so I never had to unlearn falsehood, It all ALWAYS made perfect sense to me and there was no conflict in my mind or heart. It is one of the things I love about our religion, it all makes SO much sense as you would expect the truth to do.But my mom was once where you are now. She talked to me about how she studied and had so many questions and was constantly interrupting her daily life with discussions with neighbors about the Bible, and kept on wondering if she COULD be finally learning the truth. I think she was undergoing a lot of turmoil (as you may be) and so she says that she prayed about it. Prayed very seriously to God to help her to KNOW if what she was learning was true or not.She described trying to read the book of Revelation about Babylon the Great and she said she would read a little and then go tuck in a corner of the sheet, read a little more and then tuck in the other corner. (I think she was feeling guilty as though she was neglecting her household chores because of her facination with the things she was learning).She said after her prayer and her meditating on the things she was reading it suddenly seemed SO clear to her. She said she read the scripture in Revelation about no more will the sound of a bride and a bridegroom be heard in her again and she asked herself What this could refer to? Said where else is such things heard except in the churches?It was for her a moment of truth. A moment of clarity brought on by her prayer and her prayer being answered. For you the moment of clarity may come in regard to some other scripture. But certainly DO all the digging into the Bible that you can. Get yourself a comprehensive concordance and look up all the scriptures on a particular topic. Study hard and PRAY PRAY PRAY about it.If you are sincere, Jehovah will guide you to a point where you no longer have to worry about whether you are learning the truth or not. You will KNOW. Pray and wait for his answer.

    • “I truly believe that if you study the Bible with an open mind and an open heart and wiutoht outside influences you will come to the same basic understanding of the main doctrines as you will if you study with Jehovah’s Witnesses.” In that case you have a very limited understanding of the Bible and need to spend more time on jwfacts.com, so as to realise that Watchtower teachings are false and you are in a cult.

  2. Jehovah God, ‘the One who is and who was and who is coming, the Almighty.’”So just beusace the verse preceding Revelation 22:13 speaks of that “Alpha and Omega” as coming does not necessarily mean it refers to Christ Jesus, whose second coming is frequently mentioned. Revelation 1:8 shows Jehovah as coming, and so Revelation 22:12 may do likewise. He comes representatively, through Christ Jesus. Revelation 4:8 speaks of Jehovah as coming, and Revelation 21 shows his presence with humankind. “Look! the tent of God is with humankind, and he will reside with them, and they will be his peoples. And God himself will be with them. .a0.a0. I am the Alpha and the Omega, the beginning and the end. To anyone thirsting I will give from the fountain of the water of life free. Anyone conquering will inherit these things, and I shall be his God and he will be my son.” (Vss. 3, 6, 7) This reference is certainly to Jehovah God, for he is God to the anointed body members of Christ and they are his spiritual sons. They are Christ’s brothers, not sons, so the text is speaking of Jehovah, and it calls him “the Alpha and the Omega”. So when the Alpha and Omega is mentioned again in the very next chapter, why must the term suddenly shift to Christ Jesus instead of Jehovah God? It does not.Some argue that it refers to Christ Jesus at Revelation 22:13 beusace verse 16 shows Jesus speaking. But that does not mean the speaker of the preceding verses must also be Jesus. The use of the single quotation marks in the New World Translation shows a change in speakers between verses 15 and 16. We must remember that the revelation God gave to Jesus Christ was passed on to the apostle John by one of Christ’s angels, and that this angel sometimes spoke for Jehovah God and sometimes for Christ Jesus; so we must watch for these changes and note them on the basis of content and context. It is true that when the angel speaks for Christ, at Revelation 1:17 (NW), he states: “I am the First and the Last.” But a check of the context shows this “First and Last” was with definite limitations, was relative to just the matter of Christ Jesus’ death and resurrection, as verse 18 shows. Christ was the first one raised in the first resurrection, and the last one that will be raised directly by Jehovah God. Others who follow in that resurrection will be raised by God through Christ. (John 6:40; 1a0Cor. 6:14) In fact, this limitation is also shown by the footnote on “First” in Revelation 1:17 in the New World Translation, where “First” is shown to mean “Firstborn” by one ancient manuscript. Christ was the firstfruits of those asleep in death. (1a0Cor. 15:20) When “First and Last” is again applied to Christ Jesus, at Revelation 2:8, note that again it is with respect to death and resurrection. But when it speaks thus of Jehovah no limitation is set on the meaning.So we must be reasonable. When we see an expression that is applied to Jehovah several times in its unlimited sense, and then come across it again but not specifically indicated as applying to Jehovah, we cannot become flighty and switch the expression to Christ Jesus; and especially when we note that it is applied elsewhere, not in its unlimited sense, but only with definite limitation of meaning. Trinitarians try to capitalize on this expression to show it was used indiscriminately for either God or Christ, and in this way show God and Christ are the same. But logic and reason do not allow this, no more than do many other texts in the Bible.

  3. Dear Questioner:Jehovah’s Witnesses are speaking to otehrs about our beliefs. Have you already shared some Bible truths with otehrs? If so, you have enjoyed a wonderful privilege. (Luke 1:74) When we share the truths we have learned about Jehovah God, we are taking up a very important assignment given to all true Christians—that of preaching the good news of God’s Kingdom.—Matthew 24:14; 28:19,a020.16 The apostle Paul viewed his ministry as something precious, calling it a treasure. (2a0Corinthians 4:7) Talking to people about Jehovah God and his purposes is the best work you could do. It is service to the best Master, and it brings the best benefits possible. By engaging in this activity, you are helping honesthearted people to draw close to our heavenly Father and to get on the road to everlasting life! What work could be more satisfying? Furthermore, witnessing about Jehovah and his Word increases your own faith and strengthens your love for him. And Jehovah appreciates your efforts. (Hebrews 6:10.) Staying busy in such work helps you to remain in God’s love.—1a0Corinthians 15:58.God’s Word tells us: “The great day of Jehovah is near. It is near, and there is a hurrying of it very much.” (Zephaniah 1:14) People need to be warned! They need to know that now is the time to choose Jehovah as their Sovereign. The end “will not be late.”—Habakkuk 2:3.18 Jehovah wants us to worship him publicly in association with true Christians. That is why his Word says: “Let us consider one another to incite to love and fine works, not forsaking the gathering of ourselves together, as some have the custom, but encouraging one another, and all the more so as you behold the day drawing near.” (Hebrews 10:24,a025) When we gather with fellow believers at Christian meetings, we have a wonderful opportunity to praise and worship our beloved God. We also build one another up and encourage one another.19 As we associate with other worshipers of Jehovah, we strengthen the bonds of love and friendship in the congregation. It is important that we look for the good in one another, as Jehovah looks for the good in us. Do not expect perfection from your fellow believers. (Colossians 3:13.) Seek to build close friendships with those who love Jehovah intensely, and you will find yourself growing spiritually. Yes, worshiping Jehovah with your spiritual brotehrs and sisters will help you to remain in God’s love. bh. p. 188-193.Remember the Ethiopian eunuch. He was a sincere believer in God, and he studied the Scriptures. Traveling in his chariot, he was reading the text of Isaiah when Philip ran alongside him and asked: “Do you actually know what you are reading?” How did the eunuch answer? “ ‘Really, how could I ever do so, unless someone guided me?’ And he entreated Philip to get on and sit down with him.” Then Philip, directed by holy spirit, helped the eunuch to understand the prophecy of Isaiah. (Acts 8:27-35)Christian love Mr. Cal

  4. I am thankful for the sniaemr on Sunday evening. It was very enlightening since many of my own relatives are Jehovah’s Witnesses. I thought about many things, but the following is what I pondered the most.I think it is easy to fall in to the trap of a works based mindset where we feel like we need to do x amount of things in order to be right before God.This can be the heart’s attitude of Christians in sincere Christian churches. There is something within us that does not want to accpet the complete and utter forgivness of sin afforded us through Jesus’ death on the cross. We may study it and even preach, even for years, but have we accepted it personally? I know because I lived for years in perpetual self condemnation and condemning others. In my subconscious I was a works based Christian. I was saved, but I had no peace in my heart. My relations with others was strained and I didn’t leave room for God to work. I only felt joyful when I felt I was performing well, from my own point of view. I was not taught this, but it was rooted in my own unbelief. I felt true peace when I simply believed the Gospel of Jesus’ death and resurrecton. Maybe all works based religions, Jehovah Witness’ or others are born out of this condition of heart. It all started when Adam sewed fig leaves together and tried to cover himself in Genesis.But there is the opposite end of the spectrum, that is, those who claim Jesus grace and have no works and condmen those who do works. Faith without works is dead.(James 2:26) We need to find a good balance between faith and works and discover how our Christian lives can be full of good works and at the same time depend only on the shed blood of Jesus for our salvation. Maybe people caught up in works based religious systems do not want to listen to us because they do not see good works in our lives. I minister to two people who are involved in a works based religion. They are my friends and they listen to me because they respect the good works they see. One of their pastors invited me to speak on Matt 24 once. There are opportunities opened because of faith and works working hand in hand. May God help me to find that balance and pray for others to do the same

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *